Sad to see yall go.Thank you for the years you have served us and hopefully yall succeed in all your next ventures.Running this platform could not have been easy and for that i'm ever grateful.😔😔

Thank you so much for all of this - AT has been my go-to for a very very long time. Thanks and wish you guys all the best!

Eto... admin Maji Tenshi!

@admin is the Nyaa.si Cache included in the database dump you will release?

Thanks for your service till date.

失業者だけがこれを翻訳するだろう!

Massive thanks for all the years of hosting and developing. You're a real one.

Thanks for all the years of service, AnimeTosho!

Thanks for all those years admin!

Thanks for everything

hi nzbplanet.net has also been indexing anime from here for the last 13 years, i have just confirmed with the admin they will aslo add and index the nzbdump

thank you for the many years of service, you guys have been amazing and will be deeply missed

Thank you for all these years, chears.

What else can be said? Thank you for all the years of effort and wishing the best.

big T H A N X  for everything

This site has been on my bookmarks forever. Will miss it. Thanks for everything!

It's because the site was shutting down. Everyone was venting out their anger. Now the site down sure everyone feeling miserable.

That's exactly how much your site has a great impact towards everyone. I'm one of them and all I can say is thank you and hope there's a time we can communicate again, but next time in one of your successors' sites.

I wish you the best of luck on whatever you're doing next.

> I honestly don't think it's a big ask to have Nyaa update the "temporarily unavailable" message to something more accurate.
Has annoyed me for years, I really hope they do open registration again too someday.
> such as when they decided to block proxies
I don't know what proxies are blocked, they just use ddos-guard, but I do just run a script that rotates proxies to access it, I get some 429 from ratelimit and 504/timeout when "blocked", but I don't know how that works. I don't have much trouble getting the torrents through public freely available proxies (including Tor), as long as circuit is rotated, but there are ratelimits.
> what I've seen from Nyaa indicate the owners have lost interest and is mostly just being kept on life support.
The actual mods they lost was many years ago, I think nyaa owners appreciate the value and need for the site, so of course they keep it going.
> But if you don't care about the community impact, closing registrations is just a much easier thing to do.
It does suck, I actually want an account on it, but can't get it. I do have access to an account, but it's not "mine" personally, but of course I can upload through it.
> What opsec reasons would prevent them from assigning new moderators?
I don't believe they've let in any new staff for many years. It's similar reasons let's say you're now leaving instead of passing down the torch to someone you trusted. And similar reasons why let's say the piracy scene itself (non-anime) has declined, because no newcomers, letting in new people means trusting them, trust is hard, it's easier to just keep things going with the people that are around, but you can't grow. Sometimes the torch is passed, but even then it's other older trusted members and then there are fewer.
> yet that didn't stop it from disappearing without warning mid 2017.
I don't know why he did what he did, but it was strange, he didn't tell anyone around him. Most people around him found it very strange and unusual. Personally, I hold the conspiracy theory that something or someone pressured him to close, not that he did it out of his own will. I don't know if this is true or not.
> leaving much of the community dependent on the whims of an uninterested (my view) owner is not a good place to be in, in my opinion
An archive of it is very important, and you provided that when original NT died. I worry now there won't be enough archivists in case the worst happens.
> Which is why I advocate for alternatives and think more people should as well.
They're useful, but if an alternative goes down, you still lose content, archiving everything is more important.
I'd also wish .si provided regular db dumps for this reason, but don't think they have in any recent years.
> but what do you think their end will be like?
I don't know man as I'm not them, I will instead say that people depend on some things I do and I cannot pass the torch, and if something happened to me, a good number of people will find themselves SoL, the bus factor is real. I don't know if that applies to .si, I hope they do have at least a few people with access to backups and ways to bring things back online as it's far too important to risk losing it. In general, I do have some trust that they'll do the right thing, but I can't know for sure, I suppose you have less trust than me. My trust is based on friend of a friend of a friend sort of reasons, and hoping that they'll do the right thing and contribute in the same way that I do, I can't do anything about the bus factor for me, but I hope that they at least have something for themselves.
Maybe you wanted more time or out of the responsibility too, but I wonder what actually will happen, will enough people run your code base to at least archive .si and other sites just in case? Your archiving of the original NT was very prudent and saved the community back then.

I release everything under public domain, so feel free to do whatever you want with it.

But since you brought it up, I'll add notes to the readmes. Thanks for the suggestion.

Thanks for your insights - it's always good to hear other perspectives on things!

I honestly don't think it's a big ask to have Nyaa update the "temporarily unavailable" message to something more accurate. The exact same message has been present for many years now, and I've seen it confuse plenty of users who ask about when it's going to be available again, so it's not like everyone just understands the situation.
I'd find it very hard to believe if no-one ever asked them about it over the years, but if your observation of "take care of it as fast as an hour or sooner" is accurate, maybe you could ask them and see what happens?

Anyway, small things like these, combined with messaging they've put out (such as when they decided to block proxies) make me have doubts over how much they have the community's interests in mind. This is all speculation on my part, but as someone who's seen many sites come and go, as well as my own admin experience in a similar niche, what I've seen from Nyaa indicate the owners have lost interest and is mostly just being kept on life support.

Closing registrations to stop malware sounds sensible at first, but if that's the goal, there's potentially various other less disruptive solutions. For example, they could require a user's first upload be vetted/moderated, or maybe only do this for suspicious first uploads. nekoBT, for example, requires the user pass a test and approval on first upload. Now I'm not saying these alternatives necessarily work, but they seem like they could at least be trialed.
But if you don't care about the community impact, closing registrations is just a much easier thing to do.

In terms of impact, no registrations can be a large disincentive for newcommers. As mentioned, people come and go (like Nyaa's mods) in communities, and people are less likely to come if they can't upload to the index everyone uses. Sure, the more determined will beg for an account or for someone to post their torrent on Nyaa, but there'll be plenty of those that won't bother or know better and just give up.
The kicker is that the effects of this aren't that visible - it's a slow gradual unnoticeable decline that few will care much about.

Now Nyaa is free to run their site however they like. But I don't think it's healthy for the community long term to just accept this as the way forward.

Actually, I don't really understand that. What opsec reasons would prevent them from assigning new moderators?

To be fair, that site never really took off, so could've just been written off by the owner as a failed project.
But to your point, there's certainly different levels of "give a fuck". I over-simplified earlier, but whilst I think Nyaa.si's level is low (at least lower than I'd like), it's clearly not as low as Pantsu's.

I'm sure they they understand that, but understanding is not the same as caring. Case in point would be the original NyaaTorrents - I have no doubt that the owner was aware of the site's importance (given how much traffic it got), yet that didn't stop it from disappearing without warning mid 2017.

I don't have as much trust as you do over Nyaa.si's convictions, but I do hope that I'm wrong here.
Whilst I do think they won't repeat what happened with NyaaTorrents, leaving much of the community dependent on the whims of an uninterested (my view) owner is not a good place to be in, in my opinion. Which is why I advocate for alternatives and think more people should as well.
Even if you think the Nyaa.si owners care, I still believe alternatives are beneficial for the community to have. In fact, it's arguably good for the owners too as they'll feel less burdened if they decide to move on.

Nothing lasts forever, and Nyaa.si isn't special in this regard. They may not quit for the same reasons as myself, but what do you think their end will be like?

Thanks again for your thoughtful post!

Consider providing a license for all source code repositories

<3

Thanks for all the years of efforts.

The site has been an amazing resource!

Anime Tosho Beta has graduated to Anime Tosho archive, thank you for the journey. This library is closing, thank you for visiting.

さくら動画.in
https://sakudo.in/

ひまわり動画保管庫
https://kyuzerogo.sakura.ne.jp/s_flowe...flower.php

The attitudes of the admins on the forums there didn't give me the impression that they'd give out keys, so I never bothered asking.
I also made an effort to not disclose how I was obtaining AniDB data until recently, to avoid them shutting down the API.
I assume their fear is over competitors using their data, so my leaving the TCP client in an unworkable state hopefully doesn't worry them about keeping the API alive, but we'll have to see.

Thank you for the answer, admin, and thank you for everything else. Take care.

wahhhhh  im so sad  thanks for Anime All Ep OVA the Movie Etc  thank you so much Domo arigato !!! cheers Animetosho !!!!  i was 15 years too i think i was download here too so long to download so many anime old new anime !!! not cry be strong  i will find new webosite to  download anime movie ova EP etc  search again to download anime  EP OVA The Movie etc  more pore anime Fans anime otaku !!!! cheeers and Cheer up!!!!!!!

good quality for thermometer display, the color accuracy of these are very bad atleast get from animekai or hianime, to download on android use stargon browser to rip stream of hianime etc

Thanks for the service based admin! ❤️

huh

Why don't you want to be a softy too?

You'll likely have better luck asking that question on Discord.

Some users were asking for a Discord at the time, but it's not something I use myself. Someone offered and made a server, so I just put the link there.

Animetosho Goodbye and thank you very much, for you all.

Thanks

Goodbye to Animetosho! Thank you so much for everything. I'll remember this site fondly.

goodbye animetosho

Thank you Admin for all the years you've put into Anime Tosho. Truly a heroic effort on your part. Anime has helped my wife and I through some really hard times. Best wishes :)

It's ogre.
Thank you for everything.
お疲れ様でした。

was a beautiful run, thanks for all

Good night sweet prince! May you live on in some ways! (sources, clones, nzbs, archives and so on). You will not be forgotten.

[removed]

Thanks for you work over the years. <3