How would that change anything to the Nyaanons toxicity in the comments section?
It's a feedback thread for the site, not a complaint zone for individuals to cry about stuff.
I've already hidden comments on my releases, here I'm just asking for a "2025" update on this question I asked last year.

You can turn comments off for yourself, then they won't bother you.

Membership allows Admin to better moderate, that's why most sites have it.

Better to TO someone than manually deleting comments that won't prevent further misuse of the comment section, don't you think?

Considering y'all can keep your mouth shut on a question to @Admin that was already answered by a "No" in 2024 (and that shouldn't worry you), just proves that ANYTHING is a subject for debate/toxicity.

Maybe he should get rid of the comment section all together and just keep the feedback comments.

Why would I care? Just like y'all can make new accounts, I can make a new one without any reference anywhere to NeoLX or Luxury, and you wouldn't know about it/wouldn't be able to tell. But please, keep being toxic, just proving my point (that anons are just a bunch of toxic Nyaa users for the most part).

There's been some situations happening since my last time asking, so yeah I stick to the hope that it has changed Admin's mind on this specific question.

lmao people here won't forget who you are just because you ask admin to shut down the comments for non-members. It's 2025 already. why don't you move on and do something useful? like learning how to encode for example.

thanks for proving my point that you are unable to understand the word "no". Things won't change here just because you keep asking.

You cite the "toxicity" of Nyaa comments, but Nyaa comments are member only.  So membership does not help what's ailing you.  What you are looking for is heavy moderation of comments, which I don't believe is AT's mission.

I think you need to develop some thicker skin. Who is @anon? Do you mean the admin? Your idea of toxicity and others appear to be different. I don't take "unwelcomed"  comments directed at me personally, I just shrug it off.
Your whining to the admin just makes you look like a sissy-boy.

Yes and? Still ranting about old times? That's so 2022 of you :)

I believe I said "Are there any plans to limit commenting to "members only" in 2025?", see the temporality factor here?

I'll help you : 2025.

Ofc if he says no, that's fine, but things can change (maybe the Ai-Kun troll contest changed his mind), and it doesn't hurt to ask :)

If you are unable to recognize the toxicity of comments—both directed at me and in general—it suggests there may be an issue with your perception. Allowing comments only from members helps moderation (timeouts, bans (from commenting at all, or on some criterias)), this is why many sites restrict comments to non-members.

As I mentioned, I will await @admin's response. He has a better understanding than either of us regarding the number of trolls and toxic individuals on the site, as well as whether this feedback needs to be addressed.

preach, brother. well we already know who ThisIsLX is. I guess you shouldn't waste your time. they will never understand.

It's not your site, you already asked this before and the Admin already said no to that. Or are you incapable of understanding the word "no"?

1. OK, I made an account. So what?
2. If you Time Out or Remove someone they will just make another account.
3. What may be toxic to one person may not be toxic to another.

*At this point, you're trying to defend your right to spread toxicity, not free speech.

See reply #3, Yes you are personally trying to restrict other people's free speech because you personally don't like it. I don't see any toxic posts here, just some repetitive comments over stupid comments.

1. In what world does needing an account to post comments on the community section of the site makes it "against free speech"?
2. How is moderation going to be efficient if all that can be done is remove comments manually? It's not even possible to timeout people.
3. Thank you for proving the toxicity I was talking about : " I think you are just mad  because the sins of your past won't go away..."

At this point, you're trying to defend your right to spread toxicity, not free speech.
I doubt people who have good intentions will have any problem in making an account.

I'll wait for @anon's reply, ofc you're against it as an anon (what a surprise..).

I have a dislike of people who try to restrict free speech rights. BTW, anyone can easily become a member and say the same things since you will still be a anon. I think you are just mad  because the sins of your past won't go away...

Hello @Admin,

Are there any plans to limit commenting to "members only" in 2025?

There seems to be a significant presence Nyaanons (Toxic users) on AT, and I question whether manually removing harmful comments is an effective solution.
Without restrictions, these individuals can continue to post even after their toxic comments are deleted.

Implementing a "members only" policy would enable you to impose timeouts or even ban problematic users, which I believe would enhance moderation efforts and save you time in the long run.

They've started to post again, but I don't see which improvements you're talking about? If you could elaborate? Thank you.

They made it public themselves on Discord.

TooMuchInfo: please delete specific malady, at least.
Meanwhile, respect - and patience.
Regards.

ShareAnime posted this message in Discord:

been in maintenance mode for about 2 weeks now.

I saw that but I think it's been like that for a while. I don't want to make an account on their site so I'm blocked from seeing the "guts" and was wondering if anyone else had solid info.

According to their website: The website is in maintenance mode.

https://forum.erai-raws.info/

Does anyone know if Erai-raws died? I'm a little worried after not seeing anything so far from them for this season. They really made great improvements last season so It'd be sad to see them go.